US News

Bahamas resort where 2 moms say they were drugged, raped by staffers alleges surveillance footage doesn’t match claims

2 Kentucky moms say they were drugged, raped by Bahamas resort staffers; cruise never told them about travel warning until after assault
0 seconds of 32 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:32
00:32
 

A Bahamas resort where two Kentucky mothers claim they were drugged and raped by two employees said that the women’s account of what happened does not match its security footage.

Amber Shearer and Dongayla Dobson said they were assaulted in broad daylight by staffers at Pirate’s Cove while relaxing on the beach while their Carnival Cruise ship was docked on the Grand Island in the Bahamas.

The longtime friends said they were offered a drink special by an employee, but after just 15 minutes, began to feel incredibly intoxicated.

They were ushered by a staff member into a secluded area to look for shells — and then, Shearer says, she came to while she was being raped by a man in a uniform.

The pair, covered in cuts and bruises, reported the sexual assault to Royal Bahamas police, who later arrested two men — a 40-year-old of South Bahamia and a 54-year-old of Eight Mile Rock.

Police said the investigation remains ongoing — but Pirate’s Cove claims that surveillance footage reveals that the two women’s accounts don’t add up.

“Upon further review of the surveillance videos, the allegations made on site, and in subsequent social media posts and news stories, conflict with what the time-stamped surveillance videos contain,” Pirate’s Cove beach resort said in a statement without divulging further details, the Daily Mail reported.

Pirate’s Cove also confirmed that the two employees have been fired, saying that whatever conduct they engaged in on tape “indicates that at a minimum, they violated our zero-tolerance policy.”

Two moms from Kentucky are speaking out after they were allegedly drugged and raped in the Bahamas Sunday. Amber Nicole Shearer / Instagram

Carnival Cruise Line confirmed to The Post on Wednesday that two guests aboard the Carnival Elation reported the sexual assault, which occurred while on “an independent shore excursion.”

“Our onboard Care Team provided support for the two guests as they sailed back to Jacksonville,” the cruise company said.

Dobson and Shears remembered being on the beach and almost immediately feeling as if something besides alcohol was in their cocktails.

Carnival Cruise ships Liberty and Elation in Nassau, Bahamas. AFP via Getty Images

“Less than a few [sips] into the second drink, we knew something was wrong. Something was terribly wrong,” Shearer told NewsNation’s “Cuomo.”

Even their loved ones were concerned after speaking with them on video, she said.

She recalled waking up in horror. “I came to in the process of my rape,” she said through sobs.

Freeport in the Bahamas. Getty Images/iStockphoto

They said they don’t believe their allegations were properly handled and cops did not administer rape test kits at their request.

Back on the cruise ship, the moms received the results of their toxicology tests — which showed they had a plethora of drugs in their systems, including benzodiazepines.

They had notably minimal alcohol in their bodies and bruising on their legs.

Two moms from Kentucky are speaking out after they were allegedly drugged and raped in the Bahamas. Christopher C. Cuomo/X

Just five days before their vacation, Bahamian Prime Minister Philip Davis insisted that the country was a “safe” destination for tourists.

The US Embassy in the Bahamas released a security warning and travel advisory last month saying that the island nation is currently unsafe for tourists amid 18 murders — “primarily” motivated by gang violence — in January alone.

The State Department issued a level 2 advisory on Jan. 26, just over a week before the two American women were allegedly raped.

Dobson and Shears, who had never left the country before, say Carnival should have warned them about the dangers in the Bahamas.

The pair were left with bruises after they said they were assaulted. Facebook / Amber Nicole Shearer

“We had no idea what was going on in the Bahamas, none whatsoever,” Dobson told the station.

“We were targeted from the moment we were spotted.”

Travel advisories issued for the Bahamas, Jamaica

  • The US Embassy issued a stark security warning and travel advisory on Jan. 24 after the Bahamas saw 18 primarily gang-related murders in January.
  • The US Embassy warning urged travelers to “exercise extreme caution” on the eastern side of the Bahamas’ capital city, Nassau.
  • Bahamian Prime Minister Philip Davis said in a statement the government is “alert, attentive, and proactive” in keeping the island nation “welcoming” to travelers.
  • The State Department issued a stark travel warning for Jamaica after it was rocked by 65 murders last month. The US Embassy in Jamaica upgraded the travel advisory to a Level 3, “Reconsider travel,” which is just one level short of the most severe, which warns Americans against travel altogether.
  • The Bahamian and Jamaican tourism boards are insisting the countries are still safe for tourists despite the United States’ warnings.

The women’s attorney, Nicholas Gerson, told NewsNation that Carnival has “a legal duty to warn about dangerous conditions they should have known about.”

“Carnival actually markets this particular excursion on their website, they actually profit from the excursion,” he added.

“So Carnival should have warned our clients, the warning shouldn’t have come from the State Department.”

Carnival said it is cooperating with authorities’ investigation.